| Pos | Player | Points |
| QB1 | Chandler Harnish, NIU | 20.66 |
| QB2 | Denard Robinson, MICH | 15.98 |
| RB1 | Bernard Pierce, TEMP | 22.00 |
| RB2 | Terrance Ganaway, BAY | 50.00 |
| RB3 | Vick Ballard, MSU | 30.90 |
| WR1 | Justin Blackmon, OKST | 41.80 |
| WR2 | Sammy Watkins, CLEM | 12.80 |
| WR3 | T.Y. Hilton, FIU | 17.10 |
| TE1 | Ladarius Green, LALF | 18.10 |
| PK1 | Randy Bullock, TXAM | 15.00 |
| DF1 | Pittsburgh Panthers, PITT | 5.00 |
| WILD | Zach Collaros, CIN | 4.40 |