| Pos | Player | Points |
| QB1 | Collin Klein, KNST | 21.12 |
| QB2 | Dan Persa, NWU | 4.62 |
| RB1 | Ronnie Hillman, SDST | 10.40 |
| RB2 | Zac Stacy, VNDY | 12.80 |
| RB3 | Tracy Lampley, SMISS | 9.80 |
| WR1 | Jordan White, WMCH | 32.50 |
| WR2 | Marvin McNutt, IOWA | 4.60 |
| WR3 | Tavon Austin, WVU | 40.30 |
| TE1 | Ladarius Green, LALF | 18.10 |
| PK1 | Quinn Sharp, OKST | 11.00 |
| DF1 | Rutgers Scarlet Knights, RUT | 13.00 |
| WILD | Reilly O'Toole, ILL | 0.10 |