| Pos | Player | Points |
| QB1 | Robert Griffin, BAY | 31.30 |
| QB2 | Riley Nelson, BYU | 25.60 |
| RB1 | Bernard Pierce, TEMP | 22.00 |
| RB3 | Vick Ballard, MSU | 30.90 |
| WR1 | Tyler Shoemaker, BOST | 9.50 |
| WR2 | Dwayne Frampton, AKST | 3.10 |
| WR3 | A.J. Jenkins, ILL | 15.60 |
| TE1 | Gavin Escobar, SDST | 7.00 |
| PK1 | Coleman Petersen, UTAH | 6.00 |
| DF1 | Vanderbilt Commodores, VNDY | 6.00 |
| WILD | Jeff Fuller, TXAM | 17.90 |